Chat with us, powered by LiveChat
Courses Available Online, Virtually and Classroom
Fully Certified NEBOSH, IOSH, IEMA Accredited
7-Day Customer Service
Andrew Froude B.Eng (Hons), CMIOSH, MIIRSM, OSHCR

Inspections vs Audits: What's the difference?

During my work in industry, I was often asked by a client to undertake regular site audits; this seemed like a reasonable request but often was not at all what the client wanted. In most cases the client wanted a workplace inspection to be carried out rather than a site audit. Organisations can incorrectly interchange the terms audits and inspections leading to confusion.

August 2017

Introduction to inspections and audits

*This blog was updated in August 2022 to relate correctly to changes in qualification syllabus.

During my work in industry, I was often asked by a client to undertake regular site audits; this seemed like a reasonable request but often was not at all what the client wanted. In most cases the client wanted a workplace inspection to be carried out rather than a site audit. Organisations can incorrectly interchange the terms audits and inspections leading to confusion.

So what is the difference between an inspection and an audit? They are both essential, proactive monitoring techniques however their uses and benefits are quite distinct. You will have covered it if you have studied a NEBOSH course. I’ll outline the main differences between the audit and inspection process and uses based on my experience working in health and safety.

What are safety inspections?

Inspections are a useful way of ensuring that all the things that you have put into place to prevent accidents occurring are still working and are keeping people safe. 

The inspection process generally uses just a visual inspection: the gathering of information by identifying the hazards, assessing the use and effectiveness of existing control measures; and suggesting remedial action where the current measures are inadequate.

I have undertaken many inspections during my career and this was in fact how I first got involved with the subject of health and safety. It was during my time working as a supervisor in a warehouse operation that I joined the safety committee. My role involved a site walk around trying to identify things that were not right, and decide what needed to be corrected.

Inspections help identify both the unsafe acts and unsafe conditions that can lead to accidents occurring which you do when completing the NEBOSH NG1/IG1 practical. It is worth noting that the observations sheets require you to undertake an inspection and identify unsafe acts and unsafe conditions.

Workplace inspections can be carried out by managers, supervisors, safety reps, and operatives. The use of checklists can make it an easier activity as it can prompt the inspector to look for known issues in a given area. It is advisable to target your inspection into low risk such as the condition of the floor and high risk that need a more detailed approach i.e. pre-use check would be the operation of a mobile plant.

Common Problems of Workplace Inspections

When carrying out an inspection, it is worth being aware of the limitations of them. When I became a safety advisor some years later, I helped set up a number of inspection systems for different organisations and identified typical problems first hand. These included:

  • Completing the paperwork in the canteen, ticking boxes from memory.
  • Copying the previous week’s inspection checklist.
  • Finding the same problem highlighted weekly such as a wedged open fire door, the immediate action had been to close the door, but the following week would be the same, this is a problem where the symptom has been identified but not the cause.
  • People changing their behaviour if they know they are being observed, for example wearing PPE during the inspection that then gets removed after.

So inspections serve a different purpose to audits but are a key tool in actively monitoring a workplace.

What are audits?

The process of auditing is a more complex undertaking requiring more time in both the planning, undertaking and reporting phases.

In simple terms, an audit is a detailed examination of how effectively health and safety is being managed within an organisation.

The HSE definition is: “The structured process of collecting independent information on the efficiency, effectiveness and reliability of the total health and safety management system and drawing up plans for corrective action.”

The process of auditing relies on 3 types of evidence being analysed:

  1. Documentary – reviewing appropriate documents
  2. Testimony – carrying out interviews on a cross-section of personnel
  3. Visual – from a workplace inspection

I have carried out a number of audits across a range of industries but the process always follows the same format.

Planning

Planning for the audit is probably the most important aspect as this will determine the parameters for the audit. Questions to be answered in the planning stage are:

  • Who is going to carry out the audit? The auditor should be independent to the task and therefore offer impartiality.
  • What is the information gathered to be compared with? It could be compared to recognised standards such as management systems or HSE guidance i.e. HSG65
  • What questions need to be asked? A questionnaire will be drawn up with relevant questions on the external system.
  • What documents need to be reviewed? Health and safety policy is a good starting point.
  • What resources need to be allocated? This will include the time taken to carry out the interviews, access to documents needs to be provided.
  • What is the process for giving the organisation the feedback after the audit? Standard practice is to produce a detailed audit report, increasingly now I get asked to provide a short PowerPoint presentation to the company board who is responsible for the strategy. This offers a chance to outline to the key points, questions to be asked to clarify understanding.

The Audit Process

Collecting Information, the process of collecting information is where the evidence is gathered and involves interviewing staff, reviewing documents and visually inspecting the workplace. I will start with asking about the policy, to see if the interviewees are aware of it and understand their role. I then look at the document and compare it to how the standard says it should look. Finally, I check the workplace to see evidence of the policy in action.

Making Judgements, for most organisations I audit I am looking to make two judgements: first, is the organisation legally compliant as this is the absolute minimum requirement? Second, how does the organisation compare to the chosen standard?

Audit Controls

To be effective the audit needs to be carried out by an impartial person or team; they can be internal or external.

A decision needs to be made on how much time is to be taken for example interviewing enough people, reviewing an appropriate sample of the right documents in order to get meaningful results.

Non-conformity

Non-conformity means that the requirement, for example, legal, health and safety management system or relevant company procedure has not been fulfilled.

The audit report needs to clearly identify where there is a gap in meeting the legal or preferred standard requirement and provide corrective actions to be taken to ensure compliance.

The priorities need to be indicated to allow management to take appropriate actions. A priority can be an action considered urgent due to the risks it presents or it can be a “quick win” action that is straight forward and cheap to correct. The quick wins will demonstrate to staff that things are being done and so can help build a positive culture and morale.

To Recap

Inspections and audits are two different types of active monitoring that offer feedback to prevent accidents and injuries occurring: inspections deal with the things that are the immediate causes of accidents, whilst audits deal with the areas that could be the root causes of accidents. Proactive monitoring is an essential element of effective management: it lets you check health and safety performance and take corrective action if needed.

Summary of the differences between an inspection and an audit:

Difference between an audit and an inspection


Related Blogs

  • Reporting from SHW Live 2022 Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    Reporting from SHW Live 2022

    Astutis were incredibly proud to partner with SHW Live 2022 to help industry thought leaders from around the world deliver thought-provoking speeches during the special event. Discover what some had to say here. 
    04.10.22
  • Astutis' Six-Step Approach to Successful Incident Investigations Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    Astutis' Six-Step Approach to Successful Incident Investigations

    Risk assessments and incident investigations are the most efficient way to analyse risk. Astutis' blog explores the six-step approach to investigating workplace incidents, helping organisations and individuals to effectively minimise risk in the workplace.
    12.09.22
  • The Astutis Guide: How to pass the NEBOSH International General Certificate Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    The Astutis Guide: How to pass the NEBOSH International General Certificate

    Read our ultimate guide on passing the NEBOSH International General Certificate to maximise your chance of success! Read more here.
    31.08.22
  • The Real Cost of Health and Safety Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    The Real Cost of Health and Safety

    Uncover society's relationship with Health and Safety and how it may have turned a corner. Discover the human and financial cost of neglecting Health and Safety in a post COVID-19 world. Read more here. 
    25.08.22
  • Talking Rubbish: Britain's Problem with Waste Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    Talking Rubbish: Britain's Problem with Waste

    Discover the current problem Britain has with recycled waste and how it can spiral into a waste crisis. Uncover how Britain could look to escape the problem by looking oversees. Read more now!
    15.08.22
  • Cycle to Work Day 2022: Shifting Gears on Climate Change Image
    Steve Terry

    Cycle to Work Day 2022: Shifting Gears on Climate Change

    Astutis' Managing Director, Steve Terry, takes readers through his personal connection to Cycle to Work Day 2022. Steve also points his forensic lense at the current state of the environment and asks what needs to be done to better the health of Planet Earth. Read more here. 
    04.08.22
Section Curve
Case Studies

Real Life Stories

Find out how learners look back on their training with Astutis. Our case studies give our learners, both individual and corporate, a platform to share their Astutis experience. Discover how training with Astutis has helped past learners and delegates make the world a safer place, one course at a time.
More Image
Bottom Curve
What People Say

Hear What Our Learners Have To Say

We're always there for our customers. 98% of our learners rated their overall experience as good or outstanding. We will always pride ourselves on our customer service. But don’t take our word for it, here is what our customers have to say
  • "Second course I have completed with Astutis, and again cannot fault them in anyway. Brilliant course, easy to understand."

    Andrew
    11.09.2022
  • "Easy to understand, engaging and interesting. Well put together."

    Andrew
    11.09.2022
  • "I'm being promptly serviced. The selection of lecturer and use of IT application are wise. The reference materials are fit for the cases."

    07.09.2022
  • "The selection of training and reference materials are fit for purpose."

    07.09.2022
  • "Good from start to finish"

    Andrew
    07.09.2022
  • "Quality course. Good value."

    Andrew
    07.09.2022
  • "The materials and professionalism of the tutor are top notch. Really absorbed the way how he teaches and considered it very effective."

    Edzel
    07.09.2022
  • "Learned a lot about UK legislation and Governance Principle"

    Edzel
    07.09.2022
  • "Good service and communication"

    Patrick
    07.09.2022
  • "Explained stuff very clearly"

    Patrick
    07.09.2022