Chat with us, powered by LiveChat
Courses Available Online, Virtually and Classroom
Fully Certified NEBOSH, IOSH, IEMA Accredited
7-Day Customer Service
David Bryan BSc, CMIOSH, CMAPS

CDM 2015: Three Years On

January 2018

So, coming to the end of the first three years of CDM 2015, we might ask what has changed?

The Injury and Ill-Health Picture

Headline health and safety statistics published by the HSE in 2017 for the construction sector in Great Britain suggest that not a lot of change has happened, in terms of the overall industry picture.

The Labour Force Survey (LFS) indicates that the rate of self-reported work-related ill health (musculoskeletal disorders, stress, depression and anxiety) has been broadly flat in recent years. The incidence rate of all self-reported workplace injury (per 100,000 workers) continues to be statistically significantly higher than the rate for workers across all industries (each year around 2.9% of workers in the Construction sector in GB are injured at work).

Construction Stats

If there is any good news, the rate of fatal injury is now less than a quarter of what it was in 2000/01, however, the rate of change is getting slower as the number of fatalities falls. Perhaps the 2017/18 figures might show an improvement in the overall figures, or are these numbers set to continue for the foreseeable future?

Fines Are Getting Bigger

Change has undoubtedly come to the regulatory process during the first three years of CDM 2015.  Enforcement data from the HSE suggests that the introduction of the sentencing guidelines in 2016 appears to be having an effect on the level of fines being awarded by the courts. The average fine per conviction in construction prosecutions during 2016/17 was £77,000, which is more than double what it was in the previous year. This is despite there being a 17% reduction in the number of HSE and Procurator Fiscal prosecutions completed.  We seem to be getting used to seeing the courts awarding large fines for a range of breaches of CDM 2015, based on company turnover.

The Regulator’s Perspective

The bedding in process for CDM 2015 appears to be continuing. For example, in a recent interview published by the Association for Project Safety (APS), Gavin Bull (HM Inspector in HSE’s Construction Division) provided a current regulator’s perspective on the principal designer (PD) role.

One point stressed was that the PD function is envisioned to be delivered, in the main, by organisations, emphasising that the HSE would not consider the principal contractor (PC) role to be an individual, so the PD should not be any different. In fact, CDM 2015 sets out identical duties for the PD and PC to ‘plan, manage, monitor and co-ordinate matters relating to health and safety’ with the only difference being the reference to ‘pre-construction phase’ at Regulation 11(1) rather than ‘construction phase’ at Regulation 13(1).

Challenging Perceptions

The HSE also consider that there are still many perceptions and behaviours to be challenged in the construction industry. These include the perception that designers and other duty holders under CDM 2015 can delegate the accountability for health and safety in their projects to a consultant, and that different standards apply for notifiable and non-notifiable projects. Given that CDM 2015 has been in place for almost three years now, it might be tempting to criticize organisations who have failed to fully understand or apply the regulations.  However, the HSE appear also to appreciate that, like many things in life, change takes time and may not be so easily achieved.

For example, in using a model (see Figure 1) to illustrate the emerging nature of the PD role from pre-2015 to 2020 and beyond, the HSE expect that the PD role will eventually and ‘automatically’ be undertaken by lead designers with no support from other advisors.

CDM 3 years on

Clearly, the importance of designers fulfilling their health and safety role in construction projects cannot be overstated. The construction industry, therefore, might expect that lead designers, alongside the other duty holders, will take the lead and play a significant part in reducing the health and safety risks arising from their projects.

The Grenfell Tragedy

Tragically, alongside the continuing bedding in and application of CDM 2015, we have witnessed the terrible loss of life and continuing suffering from the Grenfell Tower fire. The public enquiry is now getting underway and will hopefully provide direction as to how, from a multi-level perspective, that what went so disastrously wrong can be prevented in the future.

An independent review is also examining the regulatory system around the design, construction and on-going management of buildings in relation to fire safety, and related compliance and enforcement issues.

The requirements of CDM 2015 and the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005 are central to the present regulatory system. As such, we might anticipate the outcome of the review will provide recommendations for change aimed at ensuring the regulatory system for the construction industry is fit for purpose.

Step Up To the Mark

The construction lawmakers and regulators can only do so much. Fundamentally, it would appear that greater efforts are required from all duty holders (clients, designers and contractors) to work together to ensure the annual toll of death, disease and misery is reduced.

At this point in time, three years on, it appears essential that all CDM 2015 duty holders step up to the mark, ensure that everyone involved in construction projects take both health and safety matters seriously, understand their statutory responsibilities, and challenge those who pay lip service to this most basic of project management issues. Moving from simple compliance to a proactive and natural approach to CDM 2015 might well be a focus for all duty holders over the next few years, not just another good idea.

David Bryan is a Certified Member of the Association of Project Safety having taken specialist examinations in construction communication, health, fire, and asbestos management.

Related Blogs

  • The Future of Astutis: Redefining our DNA Image
    Steve Terry

    The Future of Astutis: Redefining our DNA

    Our Managing Director, Steve Terry, analyses the recent rebrand and the updated website. 
    03.12.21
  • The Spirit of the Union Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    The Spirit of the Union

    This year marks the 50TH Anniversary of UAE National Day or the Spirit of the Union. Find out more here.
    02.12.21
  • What is the NEBOSH Open Book Exam? Image
    Ruth Williams DipCAM MCIM

    What is the NEBOSH Open Book Exam?

    Unclear about open book exams? This blog covers everything you would need to know about OBEs and how to answer them.
    25.11.21
  • What is sustainable business? Image
    Steve Terry

    What is sustainable business?

    Read a special piece from our Managing Director about sustainable business and how our continued enivronmental efforts are making a difference.
    08.11.21
  • Top Five Tips on How to Combat Stress in the Workplace Image
    Rachel Haines

    Top Five Tips on How to Combat Stress in the Workplace

    It is easy to become overwhelmed at work. No matter what the role, it can be a high pressured, fast-paced environment that, over a period of time, can cause stress. Read our top five tips on how to combat workplace stress, for a happier, healthier work-life.
    04.11.21
  • How the NEBOSH General Certificate innovates careers Image
    Toby Howell BA PGDip

    How the NEBOSH General Certificate innovates careers

    11.10.21
Section Curve
Case Studies

Real Life Stories

Find out how learners look back on their training with Astutis. Our case studies give our learners, both individual and corporate, a platform to share their Astutis experience. Discover how training with Astutis has helped past learners and delegates make the world a safer place, one course at a time.
More Image
Bottom Curve
What People Say

Hear What Our Learners Have To Say

We're always there for our customers. 98% of our learners rated their overall experience as good or outstanding. We will always pride ourselves on our customer service. But don’t take our word for it, here is what our customers have to say
  • "Clear and detailed information with points examples from the ongoing changes in the environment"

    Antoniya Petkova
    01.11.2021
  • "It's very early days for me but everything is fine so far."

    Jaki Walsh
    11.10.2021
  • "Currently doing the General Cert & have found Astutis to be an excellent training provider, with great lessons & resources."

    Justin
    10.10.2021
  • "So far the course material appears thorough and informative, that being said I only staterted the course one week ago"

    Peter Medhurst
    06.10.2021
  • "Still going through it. Will be able to reply after completing it"

    SHYAM
    04.10.2021
  • "Excellent course. Thanks."

    Musaad AlShammari
    22.09.2021
  • "I'm enjoying the course so far."

    Mark Sharp
    16.09.2021
  • "the course is good and on a good standard but It is some how expensive comparing the income of different people mainly in Africa."

    Tugiriyera Valens
    15.09.2021
  • "Fantastic course with first class interactive features."

    Ronnie Smith
    08.09.2021
  • "Only just started but good so far!"

    04.08.2021